The June (July?) Something - 13 and 14
Jul. 6th, 2021 03:17 pmDay 13: Squicks - What are some things that squick you in fandom - not necessarily "icky", though it can be. From anything involving blood, to bad grammar.
In terms of content in fic or art, anything involving trauma to eyeballs or hands is particularly hard for me to stomach. The older I am, the less of an ability to stomach gore I have. I can't handle SAW, and I can't handle guro. I don't have much of a stomach for Bad Things happening to children, especially pre-pubescent children. They're just Not For Me. I also google if a pet dies in a movie every single time I start a movie, which is possibly a spoiler, but I do not care, because that shit bums me out, and I don't want to see it. But that isn't really fandom related, per-se. So hmm.
In terms of fandom things that squick...hm, probably anti-heavy spaces, generally. Mostly because the "shipping for great justice" sort of lifestyle isn't compatible with my id, which, as a friend once told me, can be seen from space, and mostly involves me going "WOW THESE TWO ARE FUCKED UP - WHAT WOULD HAPPEN IF THEY KISSED?!?!" (Or, alternatively, what would happen if you gave them a baby?) Like, I know it's not healthy, generally; that's part of the appeal for a lot of those ships. I don't want to have to justify my ships or read The Discourse about why they're good or bad, actually. I just want to read my fic/art about my faves kissing. The whole judgmental attitude of having to prove your ship or your content worthy of being seen leaves a bad taste in my mouth, as does the idea that supporting fictional people kissing == any kind of meaningful social justice.
(I think it can lead to meaningful social justice, mind, in that it can introduce you to concepts and organizations you're not aware of and allow you to participate in organizations for meaningful cultural and political change -- but shipping is not, in and of itself, meaningful social justice.)
Day 14: What fandom broke your heart?
Star Wars, in all honesty, and it makes me sad. TROS really removed any and all desire for me to do Star Wars outside of a couple fics I was fortunate enough to have started pre-TROS -- I'm still going to finish my "Padme as a monster" and "Vader + Leia rewrite the ST" fics some day. It wasn't just that it was a bad movie -- I'm a prequel fan, and I could have forgiven it that. Lots of bad movies have fun parts. Even TROS has some fun parts: Lando! Jannah! Rose's amazing silk blouse! But they didn't feel like they mattered a lot; the movie, to put it bluntly, did not spark joy.
I think what bothers me is just mostly that it was such a mea culpa to the worst parts of the fandom: the way it bent over backwards to appease whiny fanboys who bashed the series for years for basically daring to do something different from the OT. We're sorry, the movie whispers, shoving Rose out of the way so no one has to see that pesky Asian lady again; we're sorry, the movie whispers, relegating their male lead of color into a man who just screams the name of a white woman for the entire length of the movie and tries to pass it off as growth. Here's Chewie, he's got a medal. (Which always especially annoys me because surely no one but the audience cares! Do you think Chewbacca worries that much about a medal ceremony he participated in 40 years ago??? It would be like me being upset that I didn't get a Presidential Award for Physical Fitness in 3rd grade and harboring an irritation about it to this very day. Similarly, it's hard for me to believe that Leia's most precious item is the Yavin medal -- like, she's lived forty years at least since the battle of Yavin. Considering that battle took place on the worst day of her life, when her entire planet was killed, I think that day probably wasn't much of a highlight for her.)
The whole thing just says: We're sorry, we're sorry: Star Wars is for you again. Look here's Lando, remember him??? He's here and wearing teh same clothes he was in Solo so you know it's the same man! Leia's here too, but don't look too closely!!!! Hey look, here's Luke, he's a badass, we promise! Did we mention Palpatine's back now??? In pog form! And don't worry, we made sure to incorporate a racist background for Poe, he's gritty now! Hahahaha, like Han Solo right??? Please forgive us, we're sorry we tried to make the series grow! Never again, never again!
It casts a long shadow.
They should have done what GL did and shrug off the haters, who were never going to like what they made; instead, they embraced them. Now Star Wars is a fandom that will mostly be for older men in their thirties/forties/etc. instead of children, the original target audience. Everything is bad-ass and boring now. The Mandalorian couldn't even sell me on the father/son dynamics of it and I've been a slut for father/son stories since...well, Star Wars. I don't care about the Mandalorian, and I don't care about baby Yoda. (He's cute I guess?) Filoni isn't my favorite storyteller and I don't have a lot of interest in the last season of the Clone Wars. Bat Batch didn't grab me. Obi-Wan looks pretty blah. I tend to rotate in and out of Star Wars but I'm out for a while.
Except, of course, for the prequel trilogy politician's outfits, which I will pretty much always be there for because damn, the sheer FASHION.